The replay feature is not very stable, and a lot of errors in them which must be fixed. The data of win/defeat is stated right. However, all videos can show wrong battle replay (like immortal robots, shields that vanish extremely fast, etc.). Such errors can happen because we do not record a 'video' of the battle, we record graphic 'dots' and codes that form the battle. If some of the 'dots' have been recorded incorrectly, then the outcome can look strange.
It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!